Thomson Reuters Enterprise Centre was unable to escape antitrust counterclaims on Tuesday brought by Ross Intelligence Inc., a competing legal research service, in a copyright battle in Delaware federal court.
Judge Leonard P. Stark found that Ross provided sufficient evidence to make a “tying” claim under the Sherman Antitrust Act against Reuters, which owns the legal research service Westlaw.
Ross argued that Reuters and Westlaw “unlawfully tie their legal search tool to their public law database to maintain their dominance in the overall market for legal search platforms.”
Under a tying arrangement, consumers can only buy a product on the condition that they purchase a different product they don’t want from the same seller.
Reuters said that its legal search tool has never been sold separately from its public law database and is therefore the same product.
But Stark wasn’t convinced, finding that Westlaw’s database was sold in stand-alone books for decades before the invention of search tool technology. Third parties have also allegedly sold law databases as separate products, the judge said.
Ross also sufficiently alleged that Reuters’ licensing agreements with customers is “restrictive” and “does not permit customers to unbundle” its two products, which also amounts to a tying arrangement.
However, the court dismissed Ross’ “shame litigation” claims, which said Reuters brought the suit for anti-competitive purposes, because it couldn’t show Reuters had improper intent to pursue the lawsuit.
Reuters first sued Ross in the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware in 2020 for copyright infringement, alleging that Ross obtained copyrighted legal content from a Westlaw subscriber to develop its own competing product based on machine learning.
Want more news? Subscribe to CPI’s free daily newsletter for more headlines and updates on antitrust developments around the world.
Featured News
T-Mobile’s Acquisition of Ka’ena Corporation Receives FCC Approval
Apr 26, 2024 by
CPI
UK Regulator Announces Two New Senior Executive Appointments
Apr 26, 2024 by
CPI
Paramount Global and Skydance Media Near Merger Deal, Eyeing CEO Change
Apr 26, 2024 by
CPI
BHP Unveils £31bn Mining Megamerger Proposal with Anglo American
Apr 25, 2024 by
nhoch@pymnts.com
ByteDance Prefers Shutdown Over Sale of TikTok Amid US Ban Threats
Apr 25, 2024 by
CPI
Antitrust Mix by CPI
Antitrust Chronicle® – Economics of Criminal Antitrust
Apr 19, 2024 by
CPI
Navigating Economic Expert Work in Criminal Antitrust Litigation
Apr 19, 2024 by
CPI
The Increased Importance of Economics in Cartel Cases
Apr 19, 2024 by
CPI
A Law and Economics Analysis of the Antitrust Treatment of Physician Collective Price Agreements
Apr 19, 2024 by
CPI
Information Exchange In Criminal Antitrust Cases: How Economic Testimony Can Tip The Scales
Apr 19, 2024 by
CPI