Session 2

December 9, 2021

This discussion addresses whether there is a departure from existing principles in the assessment of so-called “self preferencing” compared to more classic theories of harm recognized under antitrust law. Many economists are of the view that self-preferencing is not necessarily anticompetitive, and may generate efficiencies. That said, recent regulation of tech companies has relied on this concept, and it has survived judicial scrutiny. To what extent should efficiencies merit consideration when looking at self-preferencing in the context of large technology companies? The panel will address this question in a detailed exchange.

The discussion also explores whether there is a difference between self-preferencing in the digital sector and self-preferencing in non-digital markets? Is self-preferencing as a legal category of practice(s) easily definable? If so, how should it be delineated for competition law purposes?

Finally, the panel will explore the plans in a number of jurisdictions to deal with self-preferencing of services by large digital platforms through ex-ante regulation. The debate continues over the pros and cons of ex-ante regulation versus classic competition law enforcement. A key question is to ask what factors should be taken into consideration by aregulator before prohibiting self-preferencing by large digital platforms?

Subtitles Available - EN / KR / JP

Read synthesis here.

Read transcript here.

Ten minutes with...

Madoka SHIMADA

Partner, Nishimura

Michael JACOBIDES

Sir Donald Gordon Professor of Entrepreneurship and Innovation, London Business School

Self-Preferencing and Online Platforms: A Universal Theme?

Reiko AOKI

Commissioner, JFTC

Tsuyoshi IKEDA

Founding Partner, Ikeda & Someya

Madoka SHIMADA

Partner, Nishimura

Marcus BEZZI

Executive General Manager, ACCC

Michael JACOBIDES

Sir Donald Gordon Professor of Entrepreneurship and Innovation, London Business School

Moderator: Frederic JENNY

Chairman of the OECD Competition Committee, Professor at ESSEC Paris Business School

Select your currency
USD United States (US) dollar
EUR Euro
Enable Notifications    OK No thanks